Annotated
Bibliographies
As
appearing in Spring 2000, Journal issue 20(1)
Keywords
used for the Index and Annotated Bibliographies . Use words
found on this page to assist in searching the Index and bibliographies.
Search for articles using the "find" capability of your browser.
Betz,
Nancy E. & Schifano, Ross S. (2000). Evaluation of an Intervention
to Increase Realistic Self-Efficacy and Interests in College
Women. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 56(1), 3552.
Keywords: career advising research.
The purpose of this research
was to develop and evaluate a self-efficacy based intervention
for women using the Realistic theme from Holland's 1997 vocational
theory.
Participants
for the study included 54 female Introductory Psychology students
who volunteered for the study as part of the requirements
for the course. The mean age of the participants was 19.9
years and the majority of the sample was self-identified as
Caucasian (83%). Participants were prescreened and included
in the study based on moderate levels of Realistic interest
and low levels of Realistic confidence. Twenty-four women
were randomly assigned to the experimental group, which received
the Realistic intervention, and 30 women were randomly assigned
to the control group, which received a neutral intervention.
Pre- and posttest measures were administered using the following
instruments: a) the Realistic, Investigative, and Social Scales
of the Skills Confidence Inventory, which is a 60-item measure
of self-efficacy expectations with regard to the six Holland
themes; b) the Occupational Self-Efficacy Scale measures student's
perceptions of self-efficacy with respect to 20 commonly known
occupations; and c) a 15-item measure of interests in Realistic
activities. The 20-item Masculinity Scale of the BEM Sex Role
Inventory was the administered posttest only to assess instrumentality
(traditional masculinity) and expressiveness (traditional
femininity).
The
experimental group received a 3-session, 7-hour intervention
that entailed building, repairing, and constructing activities.
The intervention also included the four elements of Bandura's
self-efficacy theory: a) vicarious learning, b) performance
accomplishments, c) social persuasion, and d) anxiety management.
The control group received a neutral intervention that consisted
of participants discussing their opinions of recent films.
Several analyses were used to evaluate the data: a) repeated-measures
analyses of variance were used to evaluate changes in confidence,
interests, and occupational self-efficacy over time and as
a function of treatment group; b) discriminant analyses were
used to further examine the nature of significant posttest
differences in confidence and interest at the task level;
and c) a simple ANOVA was used to examine posttest differences
in instrumentality.
Results
indicated that the 7-hour intervention used with the experimental
group significantly increased the self-efficacy expectations
of college women in the sample with respect to the Realistic
domain of Holland's vocational theory. The experimental group's
Realistic confidence increased from a pretest mean of 2.73
to a posttest mean of 3.45. This change was three times the
size of both the pretest standard deviation and the size of
the change in the control group.
One limitation of the study was the relatively small sample
size (24 in the experimental group and 30 in the control group).
However, this study is an important step toward opening the
doors for women to the same variety of occupations that are
available to men.
Davidson,
M. Meghan. (2001). The Computerization of Career Services: Critical
Issues to Consider. Journal of Career Development,
27(3), 21728. Keywords: career advising services, usage.
This article examines the advantages to using the World Wide
Web in career services centers as a mode of service delivery
and the impact that computers have on the current practices
in career centers. Seven critical issues that focus on the
implications for technology in career centers are reviewed.
Many
advantages are cited for delivering career services via the
World Wide Web. Those noted in the article are as follows:
a) career information is available 24 hours a day, 7 days
a week, and can be accessed from anywhere; b) specific career
information can be retrieved easily and quickly; c) information
is easy to update frequently; d) the need for paper is reduced;
e) users can link and refer to other sites; f) a variety of
information can be presented on-line, such as assessments,
resumes, job search, and so forth; g) repetitious tasks are
reduced; and h) users have the opportunity to be involved
in career planning and job search tasks.
An
example of career services offered on-line is available at
the University of Missouri at Columbia's Career Center's Web
site, which contains over 2,000 pages of career planning and
job search information. Student usage of the Career Center's
services has drastically changed since the addition of the
Center's Web site in Fall 1995. As a result of the shift from
walk-in to Web site service, the number of Web site users
doubled the number of walk-in students.
While
the benefits of Web-based career service delivery are evident,
some issues are important to consider in planning or expanding
career services delivered via the World Wide Web. These issues
range from questioning the appropriateness of career services
for a Web site and how on-line services meet the variety of
needs presented by students. An important issue for career
counseling professionals is whether services delivered on-line
adhere to ethical guidelines of the profession. How can career
service professionals insure that Web-based services are benefiting
students and not harming them? The author points to the need
for focusing on the high-touch aspect of career services now
that the high-tech delivery mode has been established. If
career service centers espouse a holistic approach to career
counseling, can this be accomplished via the World Wide Web?
Staffing and financial concerns are also discussed along with
the importance of outcome data that provide evidence that
the outcomes of career services provided on the World Wide
Web are equivalent to those of traditional services. In addition
to outcome research, the author suggests both survey research
and controlled between-group designs to evaluate the impact
of World Wide Web career services.
DiBiase,
David. (2000). Is Distance Teaching More or Less Work? The
American Journal of Distance Education, 14(3), 620. Keywords:
distance learning, online course, research. course structure.
The author undertook this study to investigate the conventional
wisdom that an on-line course would require a greater commitment
of instructor time and effort than does traditional courses.
This article presents data collected in a year-long study
in which the author and his assistants kept detailed records
of their time spent teaching and maintaining two comparable
university courses.
Undergraduate
geography courses were compared. One course was offered on-line
to adult professionals away from campus; the other was offered
to undergraduates in traditional classrooms on campus. The
courses had similar learning objectives, similar student activities,
and equally favorable ratings by students. Both were mature
courses that required only routine maintenance and revision.
The study was not a controlled experiment. Some uncontrolled
variables were inevitable and discussed by the author.
During
the study period (July 1999 to June 2000), the instructor
and his assistants recorded any work episode lasting approximately
5 minutes or longer. They independently developed categories
of class-related performance that included management of the
courses, preparation time spent on the courses, comparison
of classroom hours and students, and frequency of days teaching.
The
data do not support the widely held belief that teaching an
asynchronous on-line course requires more effort than teaching
a comparable synchronous classroom course. Although the distance
course required more frequent attention, the total teaching
and maintenance time spent per student was less than that
required to teach and maintain the classroom course. The methodology
used in this study would be an interesting one to apply to
a similar study that compares traditional with distance advising.
Flowers,
Lamont; Pascarella, Ernest T.; & Pierson, Christopher. (2000).
Information Technology Use and Cognitive Outcomes in First-Year
College Students. The Journal of Higher Education,
71, 6. Keywords: Freshman Year Experience, FYE, first year,
research, survey, community college, email communication.
This
study sought to estimate the cognitive impact of information
technology utilization during the first year of college. The
sample in this study consisted of incoming first-year students
at 18, 4-year and 5, 2-year colleges and universities located
in 16 states. Institutions were chosen from The National Center
on Educational Statistics Integrated Postsecondary Educational
Data System to represent differences in colleges and universities
nationwide on a variety of characteristics, including institutional
type and control. The individuals in the sample were students
participating in the National Study of Student Learning (NSSL).
The initial data on 3,840 students were collected in the autumn
of 1992. Data collected included a NSSL pre-college survey
that sought information on student demographics, orientations
toward learning, and expectations, as well as Form 88A of
the Collegiate Assessment of Academic Proficiency (CAAP) designed
to assess general skills acquired by students during the first
2 years of college. Follow-up data collection followed in
the spring of 1993.
The
two independent variables of primary interest in this study
were the extent of computer and E-mail use. Four different
dependent variables were identified: a) end-of-first year
cognitive development, b) pre-college characteristics and
student experiences in college, c) teacher organization and
clarity, and d) estimate of aggregate student cognitive ability.
Controlling for an extensive array of confounding influences,
the findings suggest that the cognitive impacts of information
technology may be more conditional than general; that is,
they differ in magnitude or direction for different kinds
of students and in different institutional contexts. For example,
there was substantial greater computer and E-mail use by 4-year-college
students than by 2-year-college students. Factors enhancing
computer and E-mail use among 2-year college students included
being a younger student, hours spent studying, and the number
of first-year courses taken in mathematics and technical/professional
areas. Study time and technical/professional courses also
positively influenced 4-year-college students. Unlike 2-year
students, computer and E-mail use by 4-year-college students
was also enhanced by their pre-college academic motivation.
Taking courses in the arts and humanities negatively influenced
computer use for 4-year students, and the effects were similar
in direction and magnitude for 2-year students; however, only
the weighted estimate was statistically significant. In an
interesting result, the authors found little to suggest that
background factors such as pre-college cognitive development,
gender, socioeconomic status, or measures of effective teaching
during college had net influences on computer use for either
2- or 4-year-college students. However, the evidence suggests
that in 2-year colleges, Latino students were at a distinct
disadvantage in terms of computer use relative to other students.
The authors warn that because of rapid changes in hardware
and software, as well as the substantial recent increases
in information technology use in American post secondary education,
their research may be somewhat dated.
George,
Orlando J., Jr. (2000). Asking Hard Questions About Technology
Training. Community College Journal, 71(2), 1622.
Keywords: faculty development.
This article presents the guidelines used for the rationale,
development, delivery, and evaluation of The Learning Community
in Educational Technology (LCET) initiated by Delaware Tech.
LCET is a model program for using technology in the classroom.
It is based on partnerships and linkages addressing the technology
training needs of college and K-12 faculty as well as students.
The
author identifies seven distinct forces for change motivated
by this initiative. Although described in term of challenges
at Delaware Tech, these forces represent those faced by other
state and community colleges. These forces include the need
to use technology in the learning process, to train teachers
in the necessary technology skills, to set statewide standards,
to address the need for workforce ready graduates, to coordinate
of K-12 outcomes, to assess tools and strategies needed by
teachers to improve K-12 learning, and to address the escalation
of knowledge and skills needed by students in a technological
age.
The
program is described by its development and delivery. Indicators
of program success are also discussed. This article can serve
as a blueprint for other organizations initiating technology
training for teaching and learning.
Hadden,
Craig. (2000). The Ironies of Mandatory Placement. Community
College Journal of Research and Practice, 24(10), 82338.
Keywords: developmental education, remedial, skills assessment,
entering students, entrance competencies.
Despite efforts made in the past decade to prepare students
for the rigors of college course work, educators continue
to find that a high percentage of students need varying degrees
of remediation to help them succeed in college courses. This
problem is strongly felt by community colleges. Most, if not
all, community colleges conduct placement testing to assess
student skills in reading, writing, and mathematics and sometimes
for study skills and learning styles. However, the dilemma
arises once underprepared students are identified: Should
they be placed in developmental classes or allowed to fail?
The literature uses various terms to characterize the dilemma,
including "access versus success," "access versus standards,"
"open door versus revolving door," etc.
The
author focuses on Colorado to address these issues through
a state perspective. In Colorado, placement testing is mandatory,
but students have a right to waive placement into developmental
courses. The overarching dilemma involving mandatory placement
rests at the heart of that which community colleges pride
themselves on most: the egalitarian position of open access
and the effort to provide all students with the highest quality
education. This dilemma raises ethical issues as well as exposes
a number of ironies, which this article explores: access versus
success, course prerequisites for college-level courses, the
junior-level writing requirement at the University of Colorado-Boulder,
performance indicators in Colorado, measures of student achievement
against national norms at the junior entry to establish institutional
accountability and future state financial support, the right
to fail, egalitarianism, and context.
The author concludes that unless community college administrators
take the step of defining entrance competencies and guaranteeing
that developmental courses will help students achieve these
competencies, they will open themselves up to the arguments
of those who believe that mandatory placement discriminates
against students, particularly minorities.
Madrill,
H. M., Montgomerie, T. C., Stewin, L. L., Fitzsimmons, G. W.,
Tovell, D. R., Armour, M. A., & Ciccocioppo, A. L. (2000). Young
Women's Work Values and Role Salience in Grade 11: Are There
Changes Three Years Later? The Career Development Quarterly,
49(1), 1628. Keywords: work ethic, career advising,
This study examined the stability of career-related values
and salience of young women over a 3-year period.
Participants in the study included women who submitted applications
for the 1994 Summer Research Program of the Women in Scholarship,
Engineering, Science and Technology. Of the 156 qualified
applicants who agreed to participate, 154 were included in
the initial sample. These women were in the 11th grade, had
a mean age of 16.48 years and a mean score on four science
courses of 88.35%. Most participants resided in and attended
high school in urban settings (n = 105). By 1996, the majority
of these women were enrolled in postsecondary education: 113
were in science-related fields, 30 were in other fields (arts,
business, education), and 6 were not attending postsecondary
or other education institutions.
The
Values Scale and Salience Inventory was used to measure the
importance of values and role salience. The Values Scale consists
of 20 value statements, each having five corresponding items.
The Salience Inventory measures behavioral and affective components
of the five major life roles: studying, working, community
service, home/family, and leisure on three dimensions-participation,
commitment, and role value implementation. These instruments
were administered initially in 1994 and again in 1996. This
study also included semistructured telephone interviews in
1995 and 1996 to review demographic information, participants'
current status (e.g., employment, education, living arrangements),
how their previous plans (studying and working) had worked
out, sources of income or financial support, study plans,
current work, and level of satisfaction.
Results
indicated that career-related values were stable from 1994
to 1996. Personal development, ability utilization, achievement,
social relations, altruism, economics, prestige, and autonomy
continued to be highly important to participants. Priorities
within the five major life roles changed over time. The authors
speculate that greater independence, increased responsibility
for personal decision making, and experience with the posthigh
school world may have contributed to the variation. Those
women who changed career fields indicated that they wanted
a career that they viewed as relevant, studying courses for
which they could see direct application, or studying a program
that was closer to their interests, once they determined that
science was not as satisfying as they had anticipated.
Out of the initial group of participants enrolled in science-related
fields, 26% indicated that medicine was their career goal.
By 1996, the number of women aspiring to careers in medicine
was 20%. Participants cited length of course, competitive
premed courses, long hours of work, and intensity of work
as reasons for incompatibility with future home-family role
aspirations.
The authors cite attrition as a major limitation of the study
as well as the study confinement to one province in Canada.
For these reasons generalizing these findings to a wider population
of students should be done with caution.
Prince,
Jeffrey P., Chartrand, Judy M., & Silver, Diane G. (2000). Constructing
a Quality Career Assessment Site. Journal of Career Assessment.
8(1), 5567. Keywords: Web site development ,
technology.
This article details the steps in planning and delivering
a quality, Internet-based career assessment system. Using
Careerhub.org (http://www. careerhub.org/) as a model, the
authors describe the challenges and ethical issues involved
in designing a site, developing content, and selecting instruments.
In designing their site, the authors envisioned their audience
as individuals seeking assistance and career professionals
within career centers. The challenge for the design team was
organizing content so that users could match their needs with
the resources offered by the site, which retained an underlying
career planning model. A four-step model was developed: a)
career change package, b) research links, c) tips for decision
making, and d) taking action. The authors discuss the ethical
issue of the readiness of users to benefit from a self-directed
site and the implementation of design components necessary
to address these concerns.
The authors discuss the issues involved with developing and
converting relevant career instruments for Internet use. Preliminary
data on the psychometric qualities of the instruments are
presented, along with the results of a pilot study in which
the site's components were evaluated.
Smith, Patricia
L. & Dillon, Connie L. (1999). Comparative Distance Learning
and Classroom Learning: Conceptual Considerations.
The American Journal of Distance Learning, 13(2),
623. Keywords:
assessment, distance learning, online course, research. course
structure.
Recently
much interest has been expressed in assessing the effectiveness
of distance learning. Often, comparative studies are widely
criticized as offering little conceptual details on the field
of distance learning. However, these studies can serve an
important role in advancing understanding of the distance
education phenomenon.
The
problem with comparative studies lies not in the comparison
but with the media/method confound. A confound factor is a
variable that, because of its relationship to treatment control
variables, precludes the attribution of change (as frequently
measured) on differences in posttest performance to the manipulation
of treatment variables. Studies with generalizable findings
control confounding factors by ensuring that only clearly
explicated treatment variables are studied.
Many
different confounds are found in media studies. The most pervasive
confounds are the media-delivery, system-method, and delivery-method
confounds. The basis for criticism is the failure of these
methods to account for differences in instructional treatments
other than those identified by the media type. For example,
in studies that compare one-way interactive video conferencing
with audio-graphic conferencing, the audio-graphic treatment
may necessitate the use of a greater variety of methods to
accommodate increased learning fatigue due to a lack of visual
stimulation. If such a study found "no significant differences"
between the two treatments, a faulty conclusion would be that
the two treatments are equally effective. This conclusion
would be faulty because a) no significant difference does
not prove the null hypothesis, and b) the manipulations of
the media were equally effective not the use of the media
methods.
The authors propose a schema system based on media attribute
theory that can be used to classify both media and delivery
systems based on research related to learning and motivation.
The framework is based on identifying and defining categories
of attributes embedded within each delivery system and the
media used by the delivery system that may support learning
in different ways. The categories of attributes the authors
suggest include a) realism/bandwidth, b) feedback/interactivity,
and c) and branching/interface. Realism/bandwidth should address
concreteness, motion, cueing strategies, social processing,
and motivation. Feedback/interactivity should address system
immediacy, overt/covert interaction and video, audio, and/or
digital interactivity. Branching/interface should address
accessibility to learning resources, navigability, pacing,
and learning support. The authors propose these categories
because comparative researchers should explain more than just
the technologies that were used: They must also explain why
and how media and delivery systems were used to support learning
and motivation.
Spitzer, Tam.
(2000). Predictors of College Success: A Comparison of Traditional
and Nontraditional Age Students. NASPA
Journal, 38(1), 8298. Keywords: adult learners,
success predictors, career decision making,
This
study sought to predict the collegiate goals of grade-point
average (GPA) and career decidedness for both traditional
and nontraditional full-time undergraduates. The author defined
traditional age as 23 years and under and nontraditional students
as 24 years and over. These students were assessed on five
personal dimensions (academic self-efficacy, global self-worth,
social acceptance, career decision making self-efficacy, and
social support) and two learning dimensions (intrinsic motivation
and self-regulation). Self-efficacy is one's confidence to
succeed at a task rather than one's actual ability. To assess
the relationship between academic performance and career development,
GPA was also used as a predictor of career decidedness, and
career decidedness was used as a predictor of GPA. It was
expected that 1. Academic self-efficacy, intrinsic motivation,
and self-regulation would be the leading predictors of academic
success (GPA) for all students. 2. The Career Decision-Making
Self-Efficacy Scale (CDMSE) would be the leading predictor
of career decidedness for all students. 3. Social support
would be a significant predictor of both GPA and career decidedness
for all students. 4. GPA and career decidedness would emerge
as predominately separate goals.
Participants were 355 full-time undergraduates at a private
liberal arts college. Students represented various liberal
arts majors and had the career majors of nursing, accounting,
and management. The sample was comprised of 92% Caucasians.
Students completed a packet of seven questionnaires and a
demographic information sheet in a single session. Permission
to access their student academic records was also received.
Multiple regression assessed which dimensions predicted the
two collegiate goals. Significant predictors were generally
the same for both traditional and nontraditional students.
Academic efficacy, self-regulation, and social support were
positive predictors of GPA. Career decision-making self-efficacy
and social support were positive predictors of career decidedness.
Nontraditional students and females had higher GPAs and greater
decidedness. Academic performance and career development were
seen as concurrent but largely separate processes. The author
discusses how using a variety of teaching methods (cooperative,
collaborative, and other less teacher-centered methods) as
well as directly teaching specific strategies to students
(self-regulation) could be beneficial for improving both GPA
and career-decidedness goals of college students.
Trusty, Jerry;
Robinson, Chester R.; Plata, Maximino; & Ng, Kok-Mun. (2000).
Effects of Gender, Socioeconomic Status, and Early Academic
Performance on Postsecondary Educational Choice. Journal
of Counseling and Development, 78(4), 46372. Keywords:
research, gender, major, career choice.
This
study examined the effects of gender, socioeconomic status
(SES), and 8th grade test scores in mathematics, reading,
science, and history/geography on postsecondary educational
choices.
Participants for the study included a subsample (N = 7,645)
of the National Education Longitudinal Study of 1988. This
subsample represented students enrolled in various types of
U.S. postsecondary institutions (4-year public and private
colleges/universities, 2-year colleges, and public and private
vocational/technical schools) who indicated a specific major
field of study 2 years after graduating from high school.
The dependent variable for the study was postsecondary major
fields of study classified using The Educational Opportunities
Finder from Holland's Self-Directed Search. Participants'
major fields were classified according to the predominant
Holland type: 6.5% were in realistic; 31.3% were in investigative;
7.9% were in artistic; 27.3% were in social; 20.5% were in
enterprising; and 6.5% were in conventional majors. Predictor
variables included gender, SES, and 8th grade academic performance
and were collected from student and parent questionnaires
and tests administered when students had been in the 8th grade.
A Chi-Square Automatic Interaction Detector was used to analyze
the data. Results indicate that gender was the strongest individual
predictor of Holland type of major and 8th grade academic
performance was the next strongest indicator. SES was the
weakest predictor, but was still significant. SES was a stronger
predictor of major choice for women than for men. Women with
higher SES were the least rigid in gender rolebased choices
and were the most likely to choose nontraditional majors.
Of the four subject areas tested in the 8th grade, mathematics
was the strongest predictor of major choice for men at three
out of the four SES levels.For women, reading was the strongest
predictor at three of the four SES levels.
The research findings in this study point to the impact of
early achievement experiences on major choices at the postsecondary
level. The authors encourage counselors to assess students'
perceptions, beliefs, and values in relation to their academic
performances and influences on choices. In addition, the authors
emphasize exploring the effects of gender role socialization
on achievement-related perceptions and beliefs. These findings
support the need for separate theories of educational/occupational
choice for men and women.
Wisely, Nancy
& Jorgensen, Mark. (2000). Retaining Students Through Social
Interaction: Special Assignment. Journal
of College Admission, 170(Spring), 1728. Keywords:
retention, learning communities.
This
study uses aspects of Tinto's model that emphasize the importance
of student involvement and sense of community within their
residence halls in facilitating a sense of belonging within
the university. Astin's 1977 research that indicated that
residence hall living increases the chances of student persistence
by approximately 12% was also used as part of the rationale
for the program. Use of differential association theory is
employed in the program to promote learned behavior (in this
case, disciplined study behavior) through active association
with others who are demonstrating the behavior.
A
special residence hall program at Stephen F. Austin State
University was implemented in 1992 with an immediate goal
of improving study skills and academics and had an ultimate
goal of increasing freshmen and sophomore retention. Two specialty
residence halls were created: the Academic Excellence Center
(ACE) for honors students and the Academic Enrichment Living
Center (AELC) for students who wanted to improve academically.
The eligibility requirements for enrolled students to be accepted
into the Excellence Center was a 3.25 grade-point average;
entering freshmen must have had a 28 ACT score or 1200 SAT
score to live in the ACE. Two halls were created for the Academic
Enrichment Living Center, one for males and one for females,
to reduce distractions and to support gender differences in
learning.
Academic disciplinary strategies in the AELC included a) supervised
study halls and tutorial sessions for close to 25 courses,
b) faculty mentor and academic advisor participation, c) programs
on time management, study skills, and substance abuse, and
d) 22 quiet hours from Sunday through Thursday with visitation
ending at 10:00 p.m. on these days. Students who do not follow
the program rules were required to move to another residence
hall.
A
comparison study was done in 199596 on the incidence of academic
probation in the general population of students at Stephen
F. Austin versus those students who were a part of the enrichment
halls. Out of the freshman and sophomore classes, 38.1% of
the males in the general university population were on academic
probation compared to 27.6% of the males in the enrichment
hall. For females, 25.3% of the general population was on
probation compared to 22.5% of the females in the enrichment
halls.
As
appeared in the Fall 2000Journal
issue 20(2)
Benishek,
Lois A. & Lopez, Frederick G. (2001). Development of Initial
Validation of a Measure of Academic Hardiness. Journal of
Career Assessment, 9(4), 33352. Keywords: retention, attrition,
student motivation, decision making.
Inconsistent findings were the result of studies of relations
between academic self-concept and subsequent achievement.
These inconsistencies may, in part, reflect limitations with
current methods of conceptualizing and measuring academic
self-concept. In an effort to develop a more sensitive measure
of academic self-concept, the authors drew upon two conceptual
frameworks: Kabassa's (1979) hardiness theory and Dweck and
Leggett's (1988) model of academic motivation. Through the
hardiness theory, Kabassa posited that three cognitive appraisal
processes serve to buffer the deleterious effects of stressful
life situations: commitment, challenge, and control. Dweck
and Leggett identified two distinct cogitative-affective-behavioral
patterns in academic performance. Students who pursue performance
goals attempt to establish their abilities and avoid demonstrating
their inadequacies. Students who pursue learning goals view
academic challenges as opportunities to acquire new skills
and to enhance their competencies. The perspective offered
by hardiness theory and research on academic motivation suggests
that, in the academic realm, many students may choose to maintain
positive self-concepts by strategically avoiding demanding
course work that may tax their capabilities, invite failure,
and thus threaten their self-views.
The authors developed an Academic Hardiness Scale (AHS) that
was created on the bases of hardiness theory and research
on academic motivation. Participants for this study consisted
of 481 students who were enrolled in a midwestern high school.
They ranged in age from 14 to 19 years (M = 16) and reported
a mean 2.9 (out of 4.0) fall semester grade-point average.
The students were predominately Euro-American (92%), female
(52%), and living with both biological parents (61%). Sixty-three
percent of the sample had clear career goals, and 75% were
planning to attend college. In addition to completing the
AHS, participants were asked to complete a battery of measures
during two regular scheduled class periods.
The
findings suggest that the AHS shows promise in producing scores
that are reliable indicators of the cognitive, affective,
and motivational aspects of academic hardiness among high
school students. The AHS, and the challenge subscale in particular,
distinguish both college-bound orientation and persistence
in difficult academic course work more effectively than did
the measure of global academic self-concept employed in the
investigation. To the extent that future research yields similar
findings, the AHS may be a useful predictor of long-term achievement-related
motivation and outcomes in high-demand academic contexts or
in the pursuit of challenging educational goals.
Flowers,
Claudia; Bray, Marty; & Algossine, Robert. (2001). Content Accessibility
of Community College Web Sites. Community College Journal,
25(7), 47584. Keyword: technology.
The Web-based content accessibility of community college home
pages was studied. Community colleges frequently are points
of access to postsecondary training and education for members
of special populations. Physical barriers are obvious problems
that limit access for individuals with disabilities, and community
colleges have made reasonable accommodations for this population.
However, on-line barriers that limit access to Web-based content
are often overlooked. To provide background on this issue,
the authors provide an overview of the legal aspects of reasonable
accommodation and summarize the Web Content Accessibility
Guidelines.
From
720 community college Web sites, a random sample of 260 was
selected for analysis. Of these sites, only 253 were available
for evaluation. Each home page was analyzed using the Bobby
3.2 software package. Bobbie 3.2 produces a summary report
that identifies accessibility limits by prioritizing them
by error types. Only 23% of the community college home pages
evaluated were determined to be accessible to individuals
with disabilities. The errors found included no alternative
text for images, need for better foreground and background
color contrast, and no structural markups that identify Web
page content hierarchy and relationships. In conclusion, the
authors determined that most community college home pages
are not accessible to individuals with disabilities, and they
present a discussion of accessibility problems. Resources
for designing accessible Web sites and methods of validating
Web sites are identified and described.
Harley,
Diane. (2001). Higher Education in the Digital Age: Planning
for an Uncertain Future. Syllabus, 15(2), 1012. Keyword:
change.
Higher education is moving through a period of rapid change.
The author argues that the nearly exponential growth of information,
coupled with the ability to exchange it more rapidly and widely
than ever before, is creating a new environment for education.
It is one in which the university may have to negotiate its
standing as the de facto source of scholarly knowledge. University
planners must also consider the significant questions that
remain about whether high-quality interactions between students
and teacher, and among students-the sine qua non of a quality
educational experience-can be replicated, even slightly, in
on-line environments.
The
author states that universities will have to address balancing
their future roles of serving an evolving on-site student
demographic while exploring new potential for-profit models
of on-line education. University leadership must be clear
about institutional goals and possible market niches when
planning to serve off-site students. Clearly, there will be
an ongoing market for residential higher education. Such institutions
will primarily invest in technologies that enhance their regular
course offerings, and perhaps they will offer secondary (or
no) on-line distance learning. The model that emerges for
a particular institution should be the result of careful planning
and reflect an approach that includes wise use of the existing
and cutting-edge technologies. It should also be customized
to subject matter, to student needs and schedules, and to
the institution's mission, goals, and budgets.
Jepsen,
David & Choudhuri, Enakshi. (2001). Stability and Change in
25-Year Occupational Career Patterns. The Career Development
Quarterly, 50(1), 319. Keywords: career advising, research.
The authors set out to identify and describe occupational
career patterns (OCPs) for over 25 years from a cohort of
170 rural high-school graduates. The authors report that research
on career patterns over the past 50 years has revealed a high
degree of OCP stability among men and an increasing amount
of stability among women. However, much of the earlier work
had studied predominately male populations. Three main theoretical
perspectives exit. First, stability is explained by enduring
personality characteristics found as people encounter fluctuations
in labor market opportunities (Holland, 1997). Second, stability
is explained by enduring social-structure features that provide
stable job opportunities (Hotchkiss & Borow, 1996). Third,
change or instability is explained by the person's adaptation
to shifts in developmental tasks expected to be mastered during
adolescence and early adulthood (Super, Savickas, & Super,
1996).
The sample in the study was drawn from 170 members of the
1973 graduation classes of three rural Wisconsin high schools.
The participants responded to a follow-up questionnaire in
the summer and fall of 1998. The return rate was 75% and is
remarkable among follow-up studies because it includes a high
number of farming and working-class members. The community
from which the sample was drawn had been settled in the early
19th century by Europeans, primarily German immigrant farmers,
and remains today overwhelmingly White and of European descent.
The complex process of identifying OCPs was begun when researchers
constructed for each individual a work history record that
spanned from 1 to 25 years after graduation. A chronology
of work positions held by each person was constructed for
five points of time. Each position was classified according
to the Holland code. Trained judges were assigned the task
of evaluating and classifying the reported occupations.
The authors reported several conclusions, but they advised
caution in generalizing from the results. They found that
career patterns, operationally defined by Holland types applied
to interval samplings of occupations, capture individual differences
in early to mid-adult careers. More than one third of the
respondents experienced stable OCPs, and stable OCPs were
associated with Holland Realistic environments. In addition,
two changing occupational patters emerged: exploratory changers
were identified as those who switched type of occupation before
their 7th year out of high school and stayed with that type
of occupation for the duration of the time studied, and advancing
changers were identified as those who began their posthigh
school years in one type of work but advanced to managerial
occupations before 1992 and stayed in management through the
25th year. Gender but not family of origin was linked to OCP
stability in the years immediately after graduation, but it
did not affect midlife career satisfaction. OCP stability
was linked to midlife career and job satisfaction and was
independent of early experiences related to family origin
or gender.
The authors argue that some of the implications of this study
support the need for career guidance for people out of school
and in the workforce. Also called into question is the often-repeated
expression that people change careers an average number of
times during a lifetime. Central tendency statistics do not
capture such job change experiences for a representative cohort
of people; hence the lore may be misleading if used in a counseling
situation.
Knox,
Davis; Cooper, Chris; & Zusman, Marty. (2001). Sexual Values
of College Students. College Student Journal, 35(1),
2427. Keyword: counseling
This study was designed to identify the social correlates
of sexual values among a sample of university students. Six-hundred
and twenty never-married undergraduates at a large southeast
university identified the sexual values that guide their behaviors
in sexual decision making. Students completed a questionnaire
that assessed their sexual value system as one of absolutism,
relativism, or hedonism. Analysis was run by sex, race, age,
relationship status, and a series of Likert-scored questions
pertaining to attitudes.
Both
men and women were more relativistic than absolutist or hedonistic.
However, men were six times more hedonistic than were women.
Other factors significantly associated with hedonism included
being over age 20, uninvolved in a relationship, being open
to living together, and a belief that divorce was justifiable.
Implications for university faculty, therapists, advisors,
and students are suggested.
Lim,
Christina Kyounghee. (2001). Computer Self-efficacy, Academic
Self-concept, and Other Predictors of Satisfaction and Future
Participation of Adult Distance Learners. The American Journal
of Distance Education, 15(2), 4150. Keywords: adult learner,
student populations, technology, research.
The purpose of this study was to develop a predictive model
of satisfaction of adult learners in a Web-based distance
education course and student intent to participate in future
Web-based distance education courses. The development of Web-based
instruction has created a new opportunity for distance education.
Unlike synchronous distance education courses, Web-based courses
allow learners to access a course at any time. However, learners
in a Web-based course are required to use a computer regardless
of their degrees of computer skill. Because adult learners
in a Web-based course must use computers, computer self-efficacy
of the learner must be determined. In this study, computer
self-efficacy was defined as one's belief in his or her ability
to use computers and to learn new computer skills.
The study population consisted of 235 adult learners who were
taking a Web-based distance-learning course at five institutions
in the spring and summer semesters of 1999. During this time,
a questionnaire was posted to the participants. Multiple regression
was used to test the hypotheses. Personal and experiential
variables were used as predictor variables. Personal variables
were age, gender, computer self-efficacy, academic self-concept,
and academic status. Experimental variables were years of
computer use, frequency of computer use, computer training,
Internet experience in a class, and participation in a workshop
for a Web-based course.
The criterion variables were satisfaction levels with the
Web-based distance education course and intent to participate
in future Web-based courses. The researcher found a positive
relationship between learners' satisfaction with their Web-based
distance education courses and their intent to participate
in future Web-based courses. The number of courses taken using
the Internet and years of computer use can explain almost
27% of the variability in computer self-efficacy.
The
author concludes that the preparation of the learner for Web-based
distance education must be considered. Adult learners are
presumed to have proper computer skills as they enroll in
the program, yet many of them grew up in an environment in
which a computer was not a household item. Understanding and
preparing the adult learner may be crucial for the success
of both the educational institution and the learners.
Mau, Wei-Cheng
& Fernandes, Amber. (2001). Characteristics and Satisfaction
of Students Who Use Career Counseling Services. Journal
of College Student Development, 42(6), 58188. Keywords:
Career advising, research.
The
authors of this study investigated the differences in use
of and satisfaction with career counseling services as a function
of sex, race, and age based on a nationally representative
sample of college graduates of different ages, genders, and
ethnicities (N = 10,080). Data for this study were obtained
from respondents in the Baccalaureate and Beyond 199394 survey
sponsored by the U.S. Department of Education National Center
for Education Statistics (NCES) and were obtained from a subsample
of the students selected for the 1993 National Post Secondary
Aid Study (NPSAS). Gender, age (traditional, younger than
26, and nontraditional 26 and older), and ethnicity were the
independent variables of the study. The use of career and
job counseling services, and satisfaction with the job and
career counseling services were the two dependent variables.
Three control variables were included in the analysis: GAP,
the risk index, and institutional type and size. The risk-index
values depicted the number of risk factors (factors that might
delay graduation) associated with each respondent (NCES, 1996).
Results
showed significant race and age differences in use of career
counseling services and gender differences in satisfaction
with the services. Hispanic and nontraditional students were
the most likely to underuse the career counseling services.
The authors conclude that counselors in higher education need
to examine their services to ensure that unnecessary blocks
preventing students from accessing career and job counseling
services have been removed.
Paul, Elizabeth
& Brier, Sigal. (2001). Friendsickness in the Transition to
College: Precollege Predictors and College Adjustment Correlates.
Journal
of Counseling & Development, 79(1), 7289. Keywords:
retention, attrition.
In
this study, friendsickness (preoccupation with and concern
for the loss of or change in precollege friendships) is seen
as a significant source of distress for college students and
affects college adjustment. The concept of friendsickness
builds on three shortcomings in college transition research:
little investigation of divestment (vs. investment issues),
underemphasis on the loss of friendships in conceptions of
homesickness, and limited application of conceptions of grief
to distress from friendship change and dissolution (vs. death).
Seventy
first-year college students (52 women and 18 men) participated
in the first two waves of a short-term longitudinal study
conducted at a state college in the northeastern United States.
The undergraduate population of this college consists of approximately
5,500 students with 90% of the first-year students living
on campus. The longitudinal sample was composed of 87% Whites,
6% African Americans, 4% Hispanic Americans, 1% Asian Americans,
and 1% Native Americans. Participants were approached during
a summer orientation program and asked if they would voluntarily
take part in the study. Students were mailed questionnaires.
Participants were recontacted 10 weeks into their first semester.
As
hypothesized, friendsickness was associated with precollege
social concerns, discrepancy between expectations and college
experiences, more precollege friends in the college social
network, and loneliness and poor self-esteem in college. The
results of this study suggest that students who are highly
preoccupied with and concerned about their precollege friendships
exhibit relatively poor adjustment to college. Friendsickness
seems to be a normative phenomenon associated with the social
challenges of the transition to college, not the direct result
of preexisting social adjustment deficits.
Implications
for precollege prevention of and college intervention efforts
for friendsickness are discussed. The most useful focus for
friendsickness prevention programming is students' anticipatory
coping as evidenced by precollege expectations and concerns.
Learned coping mechanisms are also useful in reducing the
distress associated with transitions. In addition, a preparation
strategy that involves the activation of social support can
be useful to aide prospective college students in transition.
Strategies for intervention include grief (loss) education
and peer support, tactics borrowed from bereavement counseling,
instillation of coping as a process, facilitation of continued
precollege relationship support and new friendship development,
and facilitation of cognitive assimilation of new experiences.
Perrine, Rose
M. (2001). College Stress and Persistence as a Function of Attachment
and Support. The
First Year Experience, 13(1), 712. Keywords: retention,
attrition.
This
study explored how college persistence may be influenced by
students' perceived availability of, and satisfaction with,
social support. Some researchers think about perceived support
as the equivalent of attachment. Perceived support might also
be thought of as a stable personality characteristic, perhaps
developed from earlier attachment experiences. Social support
has two equally important components: objective availability
and perception of support. The researcher attempted to extend
Tinto's student integration model by exploring psychological
characteristics that may influence the ability of college
students to become integrated into the social and academic
systems of their colleges.
One
hundred seventy-one first-year students from a midsize university
in the southeast rated their attachment styles during the
second week of the semester, and they rated their perceived
stress and social support one month after the initial attachment-style
rating. Persistence in college was tracked for two semesters.
Results showed that students with one type of insecure attachment
(fearful) perceived the most stress, were the least satisfied
with available support, and dropped out at a higher rate.
Females perceived more stress and dropped out at a higher
rate than did males. Satisfaction with support mediated the
relationship between attachment and stress, but not between
gender and stress.
Successful
retention programs offer frequent and rewarding contact between
faculty members, staff, and students in a variety of settings
outside the classroom. However, the author concluded (based
on a psychological perspective) that even if all students
are given equal opportunity for integration, all students
may not be capable of establishing the necessary support.
Because fearful students have a negative view of others, they
may find that requesting the help they need to deal with stressors
that arise from college life a particularly difficult task.
Because some students may be unable or unwilling to ask for
help on their own, retention programs that provide automatic,
even intrusive, interventions to students who need help may
be the most successful.
Vondracek, Fred
W. (2001). The Developmental Perspective in Vocational Psychology.
Journal
of Vocational Behavior, 59(2), 25261. Keywords:
counseling, career advising, technology.
In
this article, the author examines the field of vocational
psychology. He argues that vocational psychology has not realized
its potential as a developmental science, despite the centrality
of its domain across the entire life span and its impressive
use in measuring and modifying career behaviors. Rapid changes
in technology and in the world of occupations have created
new opportunities and new challenges for the field. As examples,
the author discussed the rapidly increasing number of women
in the workforce, changes in the structure of occupations,
the development of cohorts of children and young adolescents
who are "technowizards," the shortened life cycle of many
occupations, and the blurred boundaries between private life
and work.
New external opportunities bring potential external threats.
Do-it-yourself career guidance systems may limit individuals
seeking and who value the kind of comprehensive career counseling
that could be offered by vocational psychologists. In addition,
career development seems to have become as much the business
of the organization as it is the business of the individual.
In
conclusion, the author states his vision for vocational psychology.
First, it must become a life-span oriented science and profession.
Second, it must become a science and a profession that can
inform authoritatively on all substantive questions dealing
with the vocational development of children, adolescents,
and adults. Finally, professionals in the field must seek
to integrate research findings with those of other professions
to produce a more coherent, cohesive body of knowledge that
addresses every aspect of vocational development within the
larger framework of life-span development.
Bibliographies
appearing in the NACADA Journal are compiled by George
Steele and Melinda McDonald.